Just Food for Dogs vs. Hill Science Diet vs. Blue Buffalo: Which Dog Food Reigns Supreme?

Are you struggling to find the perfect dog food for your beloved pet? I’ve been there, and I’ve got you covered.

As a Registered Dietician Nutritionist, I take food seriously — even when it comes to my dog.😬 I know how hard it can be to find the right food that nourishes and fuels your pet to live their happiest, healthiest life.

After a long search, I’ve narrowed down three popular dog food brands: Just Food for Dogs, Blue Buffalo, and Hill’s Science Diet. While each has its strengths, if you’re truly committed to providing the highest-quality nutrition for your dog, stick around to see which one reigns supreme.

Why Kibble Isn’t Enough

Like many dog owners, I used to think kibble was fine—until I learned more about what goes into it. One major issue is that kibble is highly processed, requiring high-temperature cooking that destroys many of the essential nutrients your dog needs for optimal health.

On top of that, many kibble brands use lower-quality, feed-grade ingredients, including meat by-products and fillers, which are far from the whole, human-grade ingredients you want for your pet.

In contrast, Just Food for Dogs uses real meats and vegetables—ingredients fit for human consumption and cooked in a way that preserves their natural goodness.

The one with ingredients even I would eat… Just Food for Dogs

Just Food for Dogs is unlike any other dog food I’ve encountered. Instead of low-quality ingredients and heavy processing, they use real, human-grade meat and vegetables. Their meals are gently cooked in open kitchens, where you can see and recognize the real ingredients.

With Just Food for Dogs, you won’t find any questionable preservatives or additives. Their food retains its nutrients, providing your dog with better digestion, increased energy, and even a shinier coat. If you’re committed to feeding your dog the best, Just Food for Dogs stands head and shoulders above the rest.

The one that’s incredibly convenient… Just Food for Dogs

When it comes to convenience, both Just Food for Dogs and traditional kibble like Hill’s Science Diet and Blue Buffalo have their perks. Kibble is easy—just scoop, serve, and it lasts for months, making it low-maintenance for busy owners.

On the other hand, while fresh food from Just Food For Dogs may require a bit more effort, it’s absolutely worth it because dogs love the taste, and it’s great for their health. Their subscription service delivers frozen, perfectly portioned meals right to your door. You can adjust, pause, or cancel anytime—no more hauling heavy kibble bags. Thaw the meals when you need them, and they even offer shelf-stable options for travel.

Feeding fresh may take a bit more planning, but Just Food for Dogs makes it simple, ensuring your dog’s health is worth the small extra effort.

The cheaper option… Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet

Now, let’s talk about the budget. If you’re looking for the cheapest option, Hill’s Science Diet is your go-to. It’s the most budget-friendly of the three, with Blue Buffalo being slightly more expensive, though still accessible at most grocery and pet stores.

However, after trying both of these brands with my dog, Tater, I just didn’t see the same results. While both Hill’s Science Diet and Blue Buffalo are cheaper upfront, the long-term benefits didn’t stack up.

I didn’t notice the same improvements in digestion, energy, or coat health that I did after switching to Just Food for Dogs.

I hesitated when I first saw the price of Just Food for Dogs. The fresh frozen variety pack costs $167.99, but with their 50% off first-time auto-ship discount, the price drops to $84.00 – and it ships FREE!. For the quality of ingredients, the health benefits I’ve seen in Tater, and the peace of mind of knowing she’s eating the best, it’s worth every penny.

The one my picky dog likes best… Just Food for Dogs

Tater has always been a picky eater. She’d take a few bites of Hill’s Science Diet or Blue Buffalo and then leave the bowl untouched for hours. But with Just Food for Dogs, she’s completely different. She devours every meal, and her excitement at mealtime is undeniable.

Since making the switch, I’ve seen incredible improvements in her digestion, energy levels, and even her coat. She’s happier, healthier, and more active than ever.

Why You Should Switch to Just Food for Dogs

After trying all three brands, it’s clear that Just Food for Dogs is the standout winner. They offer the highest quality ingredients, unparalleled convenience, and a taste that even the pickiest eaters love. 

On top of that, their Clean Bowl Guarantee ensures that if you and your pet aren’t completely satisfied with your first purchase, you can get a full refund*. With no risk, why not upgrade your dog’s diet today?

If you’re ready to see the difference fresh, human-grade ingredients can make, take advantage of Just Food for Dogs’ 50% off first auto-ship order and start providing your dog with the best nutrition available.

*Shipping and/or delivery fees are non-refundable.

**First purchase only.